Michigan Pays You a Dime a Can, Iowa a Nickel. Minnesota Pays Nothing, and Has a Statute for the Deposit Law It Hasn't Passed.

November 19, 2026 · David J.S. Madgett

Pick a Michigan pop can out of the ditch and you’re holding a dime. It says so right on the can, because the law makes every can of pop sold there print what it’s worth and the name of the state. Bring the empty back and the store owes you a dime in cash. Pick a can out of a Minnesota ditch and it’s worth whatever the scrap yard pays, which for one can rounds to nothing.

Michigan has run that system since December 3, 1978. Iowa pays a nickel. Minnesota studied the idea in 2014, priced it out, and then wrote a statute in 2024 that talks about a deposit law in the future tense.

This is another round in the Minnesota-versus-the-states scorecard that started with Texas and paychecks at /news/minnesota-vs-texas-wage-garnishment-571-922/. This time it’s Michigan, ten cents at a time.

What does Michigan’s bottle bill actually require?

Michigan’s law is short and old. It’s Initiated Law 1 of 1976, the Legislature’s website gives it the popular name “Bottle Bill”, and its original sections carry the history line “Eff. Dec. 3, 1978”. Mich. Comp. Laws §§ 445.571–.576. The act itself says it took effect “two years after it becomes law.” § 445.576.

The dime lives in the definitions. A “returnable container” is one “upon which a deposit of at least 10 cents has been paid,” with “a refund of at least 10 cents in cash” payable by every dealer or distributor of that beverage in the state. § 445.571(d). Then the rule: “A dealer within this state shall not sell, offer for sale, or give to a consumer a nonreturnable container or a beverage in a nonreturnable container.” § 445.572(1). Put the two together and every covered container sold in Michigan carries a dime.

The store has to take them back. A dealer “shall accept from a person an empty returnable container of any kind, size, and brand sold or offered for sale by that dealer and pay to that person its full refund value in cash.” § 445.572(4). The return point has to be on the premises or “within 100 yards”. § 445.572(2). And the can has to say what it’s worth and where: each container must “clearly indicate” the “refund value of the container and the name of this state.” § 445.572(7).

What’s covered, and what isn’t

“Beverage” means soft drinks, soda water, “carbonated natural or mineral water,” other carbonated nonalcoholic drinks, “beer, ale, or other malt drink of whatever alcoholic content”, and mixed wine and mixed spirit drinks. § 445.571(a). The wine-cooler category stops below 7 percent alcohol, and the spirit-drink category covers drinks at 10 percent or less, plus any spirits-based drink sold in a metal can. § 445.571(o)–(p).

Now look at what’s missing. No plain water. No juice. No sports drinks that aren’t carbonated. No bottle of wine or fifth of whiskey. The bottle of water in your cup holder is worth nothing in Michigan either.

The $25 “limit” isn’t a limit on you

People say Michigan caps your refunds at $25 a day. The statute says something narrower: “A dealer may accept, but is not required to accept, from a person, empty returnable containers for a refund in excess of $25.00 on any given day.” § 445.572(10). That’s 250 cans. Past that, it’s the store’s call: it can say no, and it can say yes. It isn’t a ceiling on what you’re owed. (The Attorney General’s own consumer page describes the rule as stores refunding “the full deposit up to $25 per day per person”, which is the same idea from the store’s side.)

Hauling out-of-state cans to Michigan is a crime, by the number

You’ve probably seen a sitcom plot from the nineties built around this. Michigan wasn’t laughing. In 1998, the Legislature added a section aimed squarely at the guy who loads a truck in a no-deposit state and drives it north. A person “shall not return or attempt to return to a dealer for a refund” a container “that the person knows or should know was not purchased in this state as a filled returnable container.” § 445.574a(1)(a). The penalty scales with the haul:

(a) If the person returns 25 or more but not more than 100 nonreturnable containers, the person may be ordered to pay a civil fine of not more than $100.00.

(b) If the person returns more than 100 but fewer than 10,000 nonreturnable containers, or violates subdivision (a) for a second or subsequent time, the person is guilty of a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment for not more than 93 days or a fine of not more than $1,000.00, or both.

(c) If the person returns more than 100 but fewer than 10,000 nonreturnable containers for a second or subsequent time, the person is guilty of a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment for not more than 1 year or a fine of not more than $2,000.00, or both.

(d) If the person returns 10,000 or more nonreturnable containers, the person is guilty of a felony punishable by imprisonment for not more than 5 years or a fine of not more than $5,000.00, or both.

— Mich. Comp. Laws § 445.574a(2)

Ten thousand cans is $1,000 in deposits and a five-year felony. Bad trade. The court also “shall order” restitution on any misdemeanor or felony conviction. § 445.574a(6). Stores that knowingly pay out on out-of-state cans face the same ladder. § 445.574a(3).

And Michigan makes the store warn you. Where containers are redeemed, the dealer “shall post a notice” that says, substantially: “A person who returns out-of-state nonreturnable containers for a refund is subject to penalties of up to 5 years in jail, a fine of $5,000.00, and restitution.” § 445.574b(1). A store that skips the sign is looking at a civil fine of not more than $50. § 445.574b(2).

The Department of Treasury’s own data page carries a warning that its numbers “do not adjust for the impact of beverage containers purchased in another state or country and returned illegally for a deposit here in Michigan”, or for retailers who buy out of state and skip the dime. In 1992 Michigan refunded $363.2 million on $361.7 million in deposits. That’s 100.4 percent. More dimes went out than came in. Michigan Department of Treasury, Bottle Deposit Data by Year.

In August 2024 the Attorney General announced a 15-year felony charge against a man accused of faking his liquor store’s bottle-return invoices to get credits from his soft-drink distributor. The same release reminds readers that “a criminal charge is merely an allegation.” Michigan Department of Attorney General, press release (Aug. 26, 2024).

Where do Michigan’s unclaimed dimes go?

Mostly to the state. Distributors that collect more in deposits than they pay out in refunds (“underredeemers”) pay the difference to the Department of Treasury by March 1 each year. § 445.573b(2). Generally, the first $1,000,000 a year goes to a fund the State Police use to enforce the act. § 445.573c(3)(a). After that, “Seventy-five percent” goes to the state’s cleanup and redevelopment trust fund and “Twenty-five percent” goes to dealers, split by how many empties each one handled. § 445.573c(3)(b).

For 2025, Treasury reports $389.7 million in deposits collected, $270.4 million refunded, and $119.2 million owed by underredeemers, with $29.6 million distributed to retailers. Michigan Department of Treasury, Bottle Deposit Data by Year (data received as of mid-May 2026).

Michigan’s own return rate is sliding

Michigan still wins this one. But it’s slipping, and you should see how much.

Treasury’s “Total Percent Refunded” (refunds divided by deposits) ran at 94 percent or better every year from 1990 through 2014. It was 88.7 percent in 2019. It was 73.0 percent in 2020, 75.4 percent in 2021, 75.6 percent in 2022, 73.0 percent in 2023, 70.4 percent in 2024, and 69.4 percent in 2025. Id.

So roughly three of every ten Michigan deposit dollars now go unclaimed. Flip it around and the system still pays back about seven of every ten, and the money nobody claims pays for its own policing.

Iowa’s nickel, and the grocers who got out

Iowa pays half of Michigan’s rate. “A refund value of five cents shall be paid by the consumer on each beverage container sold in this state by a dealer for consumption off the premises.” Iowa Code § 455C.2(1). The store or redemption center has to pay it back “within a reasonable time not to exceed ten days.” Id.

But Iowa’s list is broader than Michigan’s where it counts. It covers “wine”, “alcoholic liquor”, beer, “high alcoholic content beer”, canned cocktails, mineral water, soda water, and carbonated soft drinks. Iowa Code § 455C.1(1). Your bottle of bourbon carries a nickel in Iowa.

Iowa’s 2022 overhaul wrote the grocers’ side of this fight into the statute. As amended by Senate File 2378, the law sets the handling fee distributors pay participating dealers and redemption centers at “three cents per container”, and lets a dealer refuse to take containers back at all if it meets one of three tests: it runs a licensed food operation with a certified food protection manager and sells time/temperature-controlled food; it hosts an approved mobile redemption system; or it sits within ten miles of an approved redemption center (fifteen in counties of 30,000 people or fewer). Iowa Code §§ 455C.2(2)(a), 455C.4(2)(a). A dealer that opts out has to post a notice on its front door saying so. § 455C.4(2)(b). Most of the act took effect January 1, 2023. 2022 Iowa Acts ch. 1139, § 20 (S.F. 2378).

Iowa also lets the distributors keep what nobody claims. “Any amount of refund value or handling fees possessed by a distributor after the distributor has made payments required pursuant to this chapter shall be considered the property of the distributor.” Iowa Code § 455C.18.

Does Minnesota have a bottle deposit law?

No. And the proof is a statute that more or less admits it.

In 2024 the Legislature passed the Packaging Waste and Cost Reduction Act, and one section of it is titled “DEPOSIT RETURN SYSTEM.” It reads, in part:

(a) It is the intent of the legislature that if a bottle deposit return system is enacted in the future, it will be harmonized with sections 115A.144 to 115A.1463 in a manner that ensures that:

(1) materials covered in that system are exempt from sections 115A.144 to 115A.1463 or related financial obligations are reduced;

(2) colocation of drop-off collection sites is maximized;

(3) education and outreach is integrated between the two programs; and

(4) waste reduction and reuse strategies are prioritized between the two programs.

— Minn. Stat. § 115A.1461(a) (emphasis added)

“If” and “in the future”. The Legislature wrote down its hopes for a deposit system it hasn’t passed. That’s a wedding toast for a couple that isn’t dating.

And there’s no deposit law hiding in the two chapters where one would live. Chapter 115A, the waste-management chapter, never uses the phrase “refund value” or “beverage container”. Container deposits come up only twice: the hypothetical system in § 115A.1461, and a clause in the packaging law saying a stewardship plan’s ban on new consumer-facing fees doesn’t reach “a deposit made in connection with a product’s refill, reuse, or recycling that can be redeemed by a consumer”. § 115A.1451, subd. 3(8)(i). That clause leaves room for a deposit. It doesn’t create one. Chapter 325E, the trade-regulation chapter, doesn’t use “refund value”, “bottle deposit”, or “container deposit” either. What chapter 325E does have is a 1975 law making it a misdemeanor to sell beer or pop in a can with a pull-tab that comes off. Minn. Stat. § 325E.03. Minnesota regulated the tab. It never put a price on the can.

What Minnesota does instead

Minnesota isn’t sitting on its hands. It has a recycling system. It just runs on goals, grants, and as of 2024, the producers’ checkbooks.

Goals. By December 31, 2030, each county “will have as a goal” to recycle 75 percent by weight of total solid waste generation in the metro counties and 35 percent outside them. Minn. Stat. § 115A.551, subd. 2a(a). A goal, not a mandate; a county that misses interim goals has to tell residents why and tell them about recycling programs. § 115A.551, subd. 5(a).

Bins. Public entities, sports facilities, and larger metro commercial buildings that collect trash must also collect “at least three recyclable materials, such as, but not limited to, paper, glass, plastic, and metal” and send them to a recycler. § 115A.151(a).

Money. The state distributes county recycling money “based on population”, with a minimum payment per county that starts at $55,000 and moves up or down with the appropriation, for programs to reduce, recycle, and educate. § 115A.557, subds. 1–2.

The 2024 packaging law. This is Minnesota’s real answer, and it’s a big one. The Packaging Waste and Cost Reduction Act, § 115A.144, makes the companies that sell packaged products pay for recycling it: a producer must “pay producer fees”. § 115A.1448, subd. 2(2). Beverage containers are in it: “Covered material” means “packaging and paper products introduced”, minus a list of exempt materials that doesn’t name drink containers, though the commissioner can add exemptions. § 115A.1441, subds. 10, 16 (2026). The dates are long:

  • After July 1, 2025, a producer must belong to a registered producer responsibility organization. § 115A.1448, subd. 1(a).
  • By October 1, 2028, that organization must submit a stewardship plan. § 115A.1451, subd. 1.
  • Producers must reimburse no less than 50 percent of the net cost of covered recycling services by February 1, 2029, 75 percent by February 1, 2030, and 90 percent by February 1, 2031. § 115A.1455, subd. 4(a).
  • After January 1, 2032, no producer may sell covered materials unless they’re reusable, refillable, or on the state’s recyclable or compostable lists, with extensions available until January 1, 2040. § 115A.1448, subd. 1(c)–(d).

The Act doesn’t set a recycling rate in the statute. It tells the Pollution Control Agency commissioner to set statewide requirements for recycling, reuse, and return rates later. § 115A.1451, subd. 7(a). And it keeps the curbside haulers’ revenue where it is: a service provider “retains all revenue from the sale of covered materials.” § 115A.1455, subd. 4(c).

That’s a serious law. It just won’t put a dime in your hand.

Minnesota already priced this out, in 2014

The Legislature asked the Pollution Control Agency to design a deposit program that would get Minnesota to an 80 percent recycling rate for beverage containers, and in February 2014 the MPCA delivered it: “Increasing recycling of beverage containers in Minnesota: Recommendations for a statewide recycling refund program”. The design was a “Ten-cent deposit ($0.10) on beverage containers of one gallon and smaller, for all beverages, alcoholic and non-alcoholic”, run by a nonprofit, with unclaimed deposits going back to the program and no store required to be a collection site. MPCA, Increasing recycling of beverage containers in Minnesota (Feb. 2014), summary at 1.

The starting point was grim. The agency’s consultant estimated that “approximately 45 percent of beverage containers may be recycled in the state.” Id., app. B, at PDF p. 20.

By the study’s numbers, the program would recycle about 107,000 more tons of beverage containers a year, “or approximately 1.9 billion container units.” Id. at PDF p. 18. The model forecast that 84 percent of containers sold would be redeemed. Id. at PDF p. 36. And the bill came to $179 million a year, covered by $76 million from selling the collected material, $74 million in unredeemed deposits, and $29 million from beverage distributors, about $0.0062 per container sold. Id. at PDF pp. 18, 36, 41.

Then no deposit law passed. The report went on a shelf at the Legislative Reference Library, and a decade later the Legislature reached for a different tool.

What would a dime cost a Minnesota family?

Nothing, if you bring the cans back. That’s the part people miss.

Here’s my made-up household: one that goes through a 12-pack’s worth of covered containers a week, 624 a year. Under Michigan’s law, that family puts down $62.40 a year in deposits. Under Iowa’s, $31.20. If they return every one, they get every cent back. If they return containers at Michigan’s 2025 statewide rate of 69.4 percent, they leave about $19 on the table in Michigan, or about $9.55 in Iowa. In Minnesota, the same family pays no deposit and gets nothing back, and whether those 624 containers get recycled depends on the bin, the hauler, and the mood at the end of the night.

A deposit isn’t a tax on the person who returns the can. It’s a fee on the person who doesn’t.

The case against a dime

There is one, and the best evidence for it comes from the deposit states themselves.

Grocers hate taking back sticky cans, and Iowa listened: that’s the 2022 opt-out and the three-cent handling fee above. Iowa Code §§ 455C.2(2)(a), 455C.4(2)(a). That’s a state that ran a deposit for decades deciding the grocery store wasn’t the place to run it.

Michigan’s slide from the high 90s to 69.4 percent says a dime buys less than it used to. And curbside programs would lose the cans that make recycling pay; Minnesota’s own 2024 Act already says haulers keep the revenue from what they sell. § 115A.1455, subd. 4(c). The 2014 study put a number on that one: single-family curbside collection of beverage containers would drop from about 74,200 tons to 12,400 tons, and the net hit to those programs’ recycling revenue would be about $0.6 million a year, “or $0.03 per single-family household per month.” MPCA report, app. B, at PDF p. 42. Real, and small, and the same study figured collection and disposal savings would more than cover it, for a net benefit of $0.27 per single-family household per month. Id. at PDF p. 45.

Notice what none of those arguments says: that Minnesota’s current system gets more cans back than Michigan’s. They’re fights about who handles the cans and who keeps the money.

What would a Minnesota deposit law look like?

A new section in chapter 115A with a refund value in it. The Legislature has already written half of the instructions. Section 115A.1461 says the Legislature intends any deposit system to exempt its containers from the packaging law or reduce producers’ obligations for them, share drop-off sites, and coordinate education, and it requires “a two-year transition period before the expiration of the currently approved stewardship plan”. § 115A.1461(a)–(b). The first stewardship plans are due October 1, 2028. § 115A.1451, subd. 1. So if Minnesota ever does it, don’t hold your breath. The statute already says it won’t be fast.

The rest is choices Michigan and Iowa already made, there for the copying or the rejecting: a dime or a nickel, carbonated drinks only or wine and liquor too, stores or redemption centers, and who keeps the unclaimed money. Michigan sends most of it to environmental cleanup. Iowa lets distributors keep it.

The scorecard

Money in your pocket for the can: Michigan, a dime to Iowa’s nickel to Minnesota’s zero.

Breadth: Iowa, because its nickel covers your wine and liquor bottles and Michigan’s dime doesn’t.

Recycling that pays for itself: Michigan, with $119.2 million in unclaimed deposits in 2025 funding cleanup, retailers, and enforcement.

Planning: Minnesota, no contest. It has a 2024 law with deadlines running to 2040 and a whole section about a deposit law it hasn’t passed.

Overall: Michigan, by a dime.

If the store owes you a refund on a shirt, Minnesota has a statute for that; I covered it at /news/minnesota-store-return-policy-refund-law-325f-80/. The can is a different story. And if you’d rather toss it, Minnesota’s litter statute carries a civil penalty of at least twice the cleanup cost, which I walked through in the fish-house piece at /news/minnesota-fish-house-ice-shelter-rules-removal-deadline-97c-355/. For another Minnesota law that puts duties on manufacturers after the sale, see the right-to-repair act at /news/minnesota-right-to-repair-digital-fair-repair-act/.

In Michigan, an empty can is a dime. In Minnesota, it’s a statute that says “if”.

Madgett Law, LLC

Madgett Law, LLC represents Minnesota consumers in disputes over unfair business practices and deceptive advertising. More on that work is on our general litigation page. If a business took your money on terms Minnesota law doesn’t allow, send us a message.

Sources: Mich. Comp. Laws § 445.571(a), (d), (o)–(p) (definitions); § 445.572(1), (2), (4), (7), (10) (sale of nonreturnable containers prohibited; return point; dealer refund; refund value and state name on container; dealer discretion over $25 a day); § 445.573b(2) (underredeemer payments); § 445.573c(3) (disbursement of unclaimed deposits); § 445.574a(1)–(3), (6) (out-of-state returns; penalties; restitution); § 445.574b (posted notice; civil fine); § 445.576 (effective date) and history notes (Initiated Law 1 of 1976, eff. Dec. 3, 1978; § 445.574a added 1998 PA 473, eff. Apr. 1, 1999) (Michigan Legislature, MCL complete through PA 114 of 2026). Michigan Department of Treasury, Bottle Deposit Data by Year (data received as of mid-May 2026). Michigan Department of Attorney General, Michigan’s Bottle Deposit Law (consumer page); press release, “Davison Man Charged for Bottle Deposit Fraud” (Aug. 26, 2024). Iowa Code §§ 455C.1(1), 455C.2(1)–(2)(a), 455C.4(2)(a)–(b), 455C.18 (2026); 2022 Iowa Acts ch. 1139 (S.F. 2378), § 20 (effective Jan. 1, 2023, with exceptions). Minn. Stat. § 115A.144; § 115A.1441, subds. 10, 16; § 115A.1448, subds. 1(a), (c)–(d), 2(2); § 115A.1451, subds. 1, 3(8)(i), 7(a); § 115A.1455, subd. 4(a), (c); § 115A.1461(a)–(b) (2024 Minn. Laws ch. 116, art. 5); § 115A.151(a); § 115A.551, subds. 2a(a), 5(a); § 115A.557, subds. 1–2; § 115A.99, subd. 1; § 325E.03 (2026); Minn. Stat. chs. 115A and 325E (2026) (full text; neither uses “refund value”, “bottle deposit”, or “container deposit”, and ch. 115A does not use “beverage container”). Minnesota Pollution Control Agency, Increasing recycling of beverage containers in Minnesota: Recommendations for a statewide recycling refund program (lrp-rrr-1sy14, Feb. 2014), summary at 1, and app. B (cost-benefit analysis) at PDF pp. 18, 20, 36, 41–42, 45 (Minnesota Legislative Reference Library). This article is general information about Minnesota law, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney–client relationship, and no outcome is promised or implied.

Get new guides by email

Plain-English guides to Minnesota law, sent when a new one is written. No schedule, nothing for sale.

Used only to send these guides. Unsubscribe from any email. This is attorney advertising — subscribing does not create an attorney–client relationship.

← All news & articles