Texas Gives Your Doctor Until the 11th Month to Bill. Minnesota Gives Six Months to Bill Your Insurer, or the Charge Is Gone.

November 8, 2026 · David J.S. Madgett

Texas has a statute whose chapter heading reads like a threat: “Certain Claims by Health Care Service Providers Barred”. It tells a doctor or a hospital to get the bill out by the first day of the 11th month after the care, or lose part of it.

I went into this one expecting to hand Texas the round. My working theory was that the only clock running on a Minnesota medical bill is the six-year statute of limitations. That theory was wrong. Minnesota has a billing deadline too. It’s buried in the insurance chapter where nobody looks, and when a provider misses it, Minnesota takes away more than Texas does.

This is another round of the Minnesota-versus-Texas scorecard that starts with wages at /news/minnesota-vs-texas-wage-garnishment-571-922/. This one’s about the bill that shows up a year late, and the bill that shows up as one line reading “miscellaneous”.

What does the Texas 11th-month rule actually say?

The basic rule is for the bill that goes to you:

(a) Except as provided by Subsection (b) or (c) and subject to Subsection (c-1), a health care service provider shall bill a patient or other responsible person for services provided to the patient not later than the first day of the 11th month after the date the services are provided.

— Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 146.002(a) (emphasis added)

By my count, care on January 15, 2026 has to be billed by December 1, 2026. “Billing” means the day the bill is mailed, postage prepaid, to the address in the provider’s records, or submitted to the plan the way the plan requires. § 146.002(d).

When the provider bills your insurer directly, the deadline is “the date required under any contract between the health care service provider and the issuer of the health benefit plan”, and only if there’s no contract does the 11th-month date apply. § 146.002(b). Medicare and Medicaid work about the same way: the contract date or “the date required by federal regulation or state rule, as applicable”, and the 11th-month date only when there’s neither. § 146.002(c). And in 2025 the Legislature added a rule for people with injury lawyers: when the patient’s attorney represents him on a personal injury claim, and “unless otherwise directed by the patient or other responsible person,” the provider “may satisfy the requirements of Subsection (a) by submitting the bill to the patient’s attorney” by the same 11th-month date. § 146.002(c-1); Acts 2025, 89th Leg., R.S., ch. 1092 (H.B. 4145), § 1, eff. September 1, 2025.

“Health benefit plan” is broad. It reaches ordinary health insurance, HMO coverage, workers’ compensation, and car insurance “to the extent the policy provides personal injury protection or medical payments coverage.” § 146.001(1).

Miss the Texas deadline and you still owe something

The penalty is narrower than the chapter heading suggests. Here’s the whole of it:

(a) A health care service provider who violates Section 146.002 may not recover from the patient any amount that the patient would have been entitled to receive as payment or reimbursement under a health benefit plan or that the patient would not otherwise have been obligated to pay had the provider complied with Section 146.002.

(b) If recovery from a patient is barred under this section, the health care service provider may not recover from any other individual who, because of a family or other personal relationship with the patient, would otherwise be responsible for the debt.

— Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 146.003 (emphasis added)

So if you had insurance and the provider sat on the claim, it can’t turn around and bill you for what the plan would have paid. Paragraph (b) keeps it off your spouse and your parents, too. That’s real protection.

But read paragraph (a) again with an uninsured patient in mind. The bar covers what a plan would have paid, which for him is nothing, and what he “would not otherwise have been obligated to pay” if the bill had gone out on time. A timely bill to a self-pay patient is a bill for the whole charge. On the words, I read § 146.003 to take very little off a late bill to someone with no coverage. I couldn’t find a Texas appellate decision reading the phrase.

And the provider who blows the deadline faces nothing from its licensing board. “A health care service provider who violates this chapter is not subject to disciplinary action for the violation under any other law”. § 146.004.

Texas does run a faster clock on network claims, in its Insurance Code. A physician or provider “must submit a claim to an insurer not later than the 95th day after the date the physician or provider provides the medical care or health care services for which the claim is made”, and the same 95 days applies to HMO claims. Tex. Ins. Code §§ 1301.102(a), 843.337(a). Miss it, and “the physician or provider forfeits the right to payment.” § 1301.102(d); § 843.337(b). The period can be extended by contract or after a catastrophic event. § 1301.102(e); § 843.337(c). Those sections decide whether the plan pays. If you’re in a Texas HMO, there’s one more layer, and it’s a good one. The HMO’s contract with the doctor “must specify that the physician or provider will hold an enrollee harmless for payment of the cost of covered health care services if the health maintenance organization does not pay the physician or provider for those services.” Tex. Ins. Code § 843.361. If the HMO doesn’t pay for covered care, you don’t either. For everybody else, the billing-deadline rule that speaks to you is § 146.003, with its limits.

Minnesota’s deadline is in the insurance chapter, and it’s harsher

Six months, and then the charge is gone:

(a) Unless otherwise provided by contract, by section 16A.124, subdivision 4a, or by federal law, the health care providers and facilities specified in subdivision 2 must submit their charges to a health plan company or third-party administrator within six months from the date of service or the date the health care provider knew or was informed of the correct name and address of the responsible health plan company or third-party administrator, whichever is later.

(b) A health care provider or facility that does not make an initial submission of charges within the six-month period in paragraph (a), the 12-month period in paragraph (c), or the additional six-month period in paragraph (d) shall not be reimbursed for the charge and may not collect the charge from the recipient of the service or any other payer.

— Minn. Stat. § 62Q.75, subd. 3 (emphasis added)

That’s the difference. Texas bars what the plan would have paid and what you wouldn’t otherwise owe. Minnesota bars “the charge”. From you, and from “any other payer.” I read that to take the whole charge off the table, not just the insurer’s share.

The qualifiers matter. A contract between the provider and your plan, or federal law, can set a different period. A provider that can substantiate “a significant disruption to normal operations that materially affects the ability to conduct business in a normal manner and to submit claims on a timely basis” can stretch the six months to 12. § 62Q.75, subd. 3(c). In 2025 the Legislature added a second six months that starts when the plan adjusts or recoups a payment. § 62Q.75, subd. 3(d); 2025 Minn. Laws ch. 38, art. 9, § 1. And the clock doesn’t start until the provider knew, or was told, the correct name and address of your plan. If the front desk had the wrong card on file, the six months starts late.

Then the part almost nobody knows. The rule “also applies to all health care providers and facilities that submit charges to workers’ compensation payers for treatment of a workers’ compensation injury compensable under chapter 176, or to reparation obligors for treatment of an injury compensable under chapter 65B.” § 62Q.75, subd. 3(g). Chapter 65B is no-fault auto. So a clinic treating you after a crash has six months to bill your no-fault carrier. I wrote about how Minnesota’s no-fault system works at /news/minnesota-no-fault-auto-basics/.

A Minnesota court has already said what it means for the patient

In 2017 the Minnesota Court of Appeals took up a man hurt in a 2011 crash. His imaging clinic billed his no-fault insurer for one early visit and never submitted another bill, though his charges ended up over $10,000. W. Nat’l Ins. Co. v. Nguyen, 902 N.W.2d 645, 647–48 (Minn. Ct. App. 2017). The court held the six-month rule reaches no-fault claims, and then said what it means for the patient: the clinic “could not collect those charges from Western National or Nguyen.” Id. at 650. That meant the patient had never incurred the expense at all. The court put two statutes together: § 62Q.75, and the no-fault act’s own rule that a claim not sent to the insurer in the required electronic format isn’t due. Between them, it said, he “cannot be liable for a charge that the health-care provider ‘may not collect’ for a bill that is ‘not due.’” Id. at 650–51; see Minn. Stat. § 65B.54, subd. 1.

The Minnesota Supreme Court took the case and split evenly, which left the court of appeals’ decision standing. The order affirmed it “without opinion” on “an evenly divided court”. W. Nat’l Ins. Co. v. Nguyen, 909 N.W.2d 341 (Minn. 2018) (mem.).

That cut against the patient’s no-fault claim in that case. Flip it around and it’s the rule you want when a clinic mails you a two-year-old bill it never sent to your insurer.

What if you don’t have insurance at all?

Then Minnesota has no billing deadline, and Texas has one with very little behind it.

Minnesota’s six-month rule is about submitting charges “to a health plan company or third-party administrator”, and it doesn’t speak to a bill sent to a self-pay patient. I looked for any other clock. I read the 2024 billing-error, collection-policy, and denial-of-treatment sections, Minn. Stat. §§ 62J.805 through 62J.808, and the 2023 charity-care section, § 144.587, and none sets a deadline for billing the patient. I searched the Revisor’s index of the 2026 statutes for “bill a patient”, “billing the patient”, “may not bill the patient”, “from the date of service”, and “after the date of service”. The first three returned nothing. The fourth turned up § 62Q.75 and nothing else on medical billing. The fifth turned up nothing on medical billing at all.

So the only clock on a self-pay Minnesota medical bill is the one on every consumer debt: an action “shall be commenced within six years.” Minn. Stat. § 541.053. A collecting party also can’t “commence legal action to collect a medical debt outside the limitations period set forth in section 541.053”. § 332C.02(19). I compared Minnesota’s six years with the Texas clock on consumer debt at /news/minnesota-vs-texas-time-barred-credit-card-debt-541-053/.

Texas at least tells the provider to bill the uninsured patient by the 11th month. But as I read § 146.003, the penalty for missing it doesn’t take much off the bill. Neither state protects the self-pay patient from a slow bill. Texas just wrote down the expectation.

Who has to send me an itemized bill?

Both states. Only one of them stops the collection until you get it.

Minnesota went first. Since August 1, 2020, every Minnesota hospital “shall provide to each discharged patient within 30 calendar days of discharge an itemized description of billed charges for medical services and goods the patient received during the hospital stay.” Minn. Stat. § 144.591(a); 2019 Minn. Laws 1st Spec. Sess. ch. 9, art. 11, § 35. It can’t describe a charge “using only a medical billing code, ‘miscellaneous charges,’ or ‘supply charges.’” § 144.591(a). The hospital can’t charge you for it. § 144.591(b). That’s automatic. You don’t have to ask.

But it doesn’t reach patients “enrolled in Medicare, medical assistance, the MinnesotaCare program, or who receive health care coverage through an employer self-insured health plan.” § 144.591(d). And the section names no penalty and no consequence for a hospital that skips it.

Texas came in 2023 with S.B. 490, and it wrote the consequence in:

(e) A health care provider may not pursue debt collection against a patient for a provided health care service or supply unless the provider has complied with this section.

— Tex. Health & Safety Code § 185.002(e) (emphasis added)

The duty kicks in when a provider “requests payment from a patient”, and the bill has to go out “not later than the 30th day after the provider receives a final payment on the provided service or supply from a third party.” § 185.002(a). It has to give “a plain language description of each distinct health care service or supply”, any billing code sent to an insurer “and the amounts billed to and paid by that third party”, and what the provider says you owe for each item. § 185.002(b). Texas borrows its definition of “debt collection” from the Finance Code: “an action, conduct, or practice in collecting, or in soliciting for collection, consumer debts”. Tex. Fin. Code § 392.001(5). On those words, the bar reaches the provider’s own billing office, not just an agency.

The licensing authority “shall take disciplinary action” against a provider that violates the chapter, unless the provider mailed a hard copy in good faith and it came back undeliverable or lost, or went to an address that wasn’t current. Tex. Health & Safety Code § 185.003. Two limits: “health care provider” here means a licensed facility, including a hospital, and leaves out federally qualified health centers. § 185.001(2). And a provider that posts the bill to a patient portal has to mail, email, or hand over a copy if it finds you don’t have an active portal profile or can’t tell. § 185.002(c-1).

Texas wins this one. Minnesota’s rule is older and automatic, and on its own words it has no teeth. Texas’s says no bill, no collection.

Where Minnesota pulls away

Everything after the bill goes out is where Minnesota’s 2024 Debt Fairness Act lives, and I walked through it section by section at /news/minnesota-medical-debt-fairness-act/. That piece also covers a rule that’s older than the Act: since 2023, a Minnesota hospital has had to settle your charity-care eligibility before it sends your bill to collections. Minn. Stat. § 144.587, subd. 4(a); 2023 Minn. Laws ch. 70, art. 4, § 40. I won’t re-walk it. Just set two pieces next to the Texas statute books.

Credit reports. Minnesota says a collecting party “is prohibited from reporting medical debt to a consumer reporting agency”, and the bureau can’t put it in a report either. Minn. Stat. § 332C.03(a)–(b). Texas’s version, in its credit-reporting statute, bars a medical collection only “if the consumer was covered by a health benefit plan at the time of the event giving rise to the collection” and the balance, “after copayments, deductibles, and coinsurance,” is owed “to an emergency care provider or a facility-based provider for an out-of-network benefit claim”. Tex. Bus. & Com. Code § 20.05(a)(5). Even that narrow bar gives way when the report is for a credit transaction “with a principal amount that is or may reasonably be expected to be $150,000 or more”. § 20.05(b)(1). Whether Minnesota’s broader ban survives federal preemption is a live fight, and it’s in the Debt Fairness Act piece. If a medical collection that shouldn’t be there is on your report anyway, that’s the kind of dispute our Credit File Corrections practice handles.

Your spouse. In Minnesota, “A spouse is not liable to a creditor for any debts of the other spouse.” Minn. Stat. § 519.05(a). In Texas, a person is personally liable for a spouse’s acts if “the spouse incurs a debt for necessaries as provided by Subchapter F, Chapter 2.” Tex. Fam. Code § 3.201(a)(2). I covered the Minnesota rule, and the joint-account trap it leaves open, at /news/minnesota-spouse-debt-liability-519-05/.

The scorecard

Insured patient, slow provider: Minnesota, unless you’re in a Texas HMO, whose contracts have to hold you harmless when the HMO doesn’t pay. Texas runs a faster 95-day clock on network claims and forfeits the provider’s right to payment from the plan, but its billing-deadline statute protects you only from what the plan would have paid and what you wouldn’t otherwise have owed. Minnesota’s stops the charge, from you and from anyone else, and it reaches no-fault and workers’ comp bills too.

Uninsured patient, slow provider: a draw, and a bad one. Texas has a deadline that, on my reading, barely bites. Minnesota has six years.

Itemized bill: Texas, because its rule stops the collection.

Credit reports and spouses: Minnesota, and not close.

If a provider just billed you for care from a year and a half ago, the first question in either state is whether your insurer ever saw the bill. In Minnesota, the answer can end the debt.

Madgett Law, LLC

Madgett Law, LLC defends Minnesotans sued on consumer and medical debt, pursues claims against collectors who break chapter 332C, and handles the credit-reporting fallout when a medical bill lands on a credit file. We also help people look at negotiated alternatives before a judgment narrows the options; that work is on our bankruptcy avoidance page. If you’re holding a medical bill that showed up long after the care, or one that says “miscellaneous” and nothing else, send us a message.

Sources: Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 146.001(1) (health benefit plan), § 146.002(a)–(d) (timely billing; contract and federal-rule deadlines; attorney submission; date of billing) and history note (Acts 2025, 89th Leg., R.S., ch. 1092 (H.B. 4145), § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 2025), § 146.003(a)–(b) (claims barred), § 146.004 (no disciplinary action); Tex. Ins. Code § 843.337(a)–(c) (HMO claim submission, 95 days, forfeiture, extensions), § 843.361 (HMO contracts must hold enrollees harmless), § 1301.102(a), (d), (e) (insurer claim submission, 95 days, forfeiture, extensions); Tex. Health & Safety Code § 185.001(2) (health care provider), § 185.002(a)–(e) (itemized bill; contents; portal rule; bar on debt collection) and history note (Acts 2023, 88th Leg., R.S., ch. 271 (S.B. 490), § 1, eff. Sept. 1, 2023; Acts 2025, 89th Leg., R.S., ch. 717 (H.B. 216)), § 185.003 (disciplinary action; good-faith mailing exception); Tex. Fin. Code § 392.001(5) (debt collection); Tex. Bus. & Com. Code § 20.05(a)(5), (b)(1) (medical collection accounts on consumer reports; $150,000 credit-transaction exception); Tex. Fam. Code § 3.201(a)(2) (spousal liability for necessaries) (Texas Constitution and Statutes, Texas Legislative Council). Minn. Stat. § 62Q.75, subd. 3(a)–(d), (g) (claims filing; six months; bar on reimbursement and collection; extensions; workers’ compensation and no-fault); 2025 Minn. Laws ch. 38, art. 9, § 1 (adding the additional six-month period); §§ 62J.805–62J.808 (billing errors; collection policy; denial of treatment); § 144.587, subd. 4(a) (actions barred before charity-care determination); 2023 Minn. Laws ch. 70, art. 4, § 40 (enacting § 144.587); § 65B.54, subd. 1 (no-fault medical claims not due unless submitted under electronic standards); § 144.591(a)–(b), (d) (hospital itemized description of billed charges; exclusions); 2019 Minn. Laws 1st Spec. Sess. ch. 9, art. 11, § 35 (enacting § 144.591; effective Aug. 1, 2020); § 332C.02(19) (no action outside § 541.053); § 332C.03(a)–(b) (medical debt reporting prohibited); § 519.05(a) (liability of spouses); § 541.053 (six-year limitations period for consumer debt); Revisor of Statutes statute search, 2026 edition. W. Nat’l Ins. Co. v. Nguyen, 902 N.W.2d 645, 647–48, 650–51 (Minn. Ct. App. 2017), aff’d mem., 909 N.W.2d 341 (Minn. 2018). This article is general information about Minnesota law, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney–client relationship, and no outcome is promised or implied.

Get new guides by email

Plain-English guides to Minnesota law, sent when a new one is written. No schedule, nothing for sale.

Used only to send these guides. Unsubscribe from any email. This is attorney advertising — subscribing does not create an attorney–client relationship.

← All news & articles