Texas fines an employer who stiffs a fired worker on the last paycheck. Then it deposits the fine in the state’s unemployment compensation special administration fund. The worker gets the wages he was owed in the first place, eventually, plus whatever interest they earned while the Commission held them. No penalty for the wait.
Minnesota does it the other way around. Every day the employer stays in default after a written demand, the worker can charge it another day’s pay, up to 15 days of it. And if it goes to court, the employer that loses pays the worker’s lawyer too.
Both states have had a prompt-pay law on the books for more than a century: the Supreme Court of Texas dates the first Texas Payday Law to 1915, Igal v. Brightstar Info. Tech. Grp., Inc., 250 S.W.3d 78, 81 (Tex. 2008), and Minnesota’s final-paycheck penalty traces to a 1919 session law. They went in opposite directions on who gets paid when an employer drags its feet. This is another round in my Minnesota-vs-Texas series, which started on the paycheck at /news/minnesota-vs-texas-wage-garnishment-571-922/. That one was about a creditor taking your pay. This one is about your employer sitting on it.
How fast does a Minnesota employer have to pay a fired worker?
As fast as you ask. When a Minnesota employer discharges an employee, the wages “actually earned and unpaid at the time of the discharge are immediately due and payable upon demand of the employee.” Minn. Stat. § 181.13(a). If they aren’t paid “within 24 hours after demand,” the employer “is in default.” Id. And then the meter starts:
In addition to recovering the wages and commissions actually earned and unpaid, the discharged employee may charge and collect a penalty equal to the amount of the employee’s average daily earnings at the employee’s regular rate of pay or the rate required by law, whichever rate is greater, for each day up to 15 days, that the employer is in default, until full payment or other settlement, satisfactory to the discharged employee, is made.
— Minn. Stat. § 181.13(a) (emphasis added)
Put a number on it. A worker whose average daily earnings come to $200 can charge up to $3,000 on top of the unpaid wages if the employer sits on the check for 15 days after the demand. Then the fee statute kicks in. In a lawsuit under § 181.171, the court “shall order an employer who is found to have committed a violation to pay to the aggrieved party reasonable costs, disbursements, witness fees, and attorney fees.” Minn. Stat. § 181.171, subd. 3. Shall. A $3,000 penalty fight can come with a lawyer’s bill on top, and the employer who lost pays it.
A worker who quits is on a slower clock. The wages are due “not later than the first regularly scheduled payday following the employee’s final day of employment,” and if that payday is less than five calendar days out, the employer may wait for the second one, but never more than “a total of 20 calendar days” after the last day. Minn. Stat. § 181.14, subd. 1(a). A union contract can change that clock: the payday rule applies “unless an employee is subject to a collective bargaining agreement with a different provision”. Id. Miss that, and the same demand, the same 24 hours, and the same 15-day penalty apply. § 181.14, subd. 2.
I walked the whole Minnesota statute, including the good-faith tender that caps an employer’s exposure and the ten-day audit window for employees who handled money, at /news/minnesota-final-paycheck-181-13/. I won’t repeat it here. What matters for this round is who the penalty goes to. In Minnesota, it goes to you.
Texas gives the employer six days, and you don’t have to ask
Here’s where Texas is better.
The Texas Payday Law says an employer “shall pay in full an employee who is discharged from employment not later than the sixth day after the date the employee is discharged.” Tex. Lab. Code § 61.014(a). A “day” means “a calendar day.” § 61.001(2). An employee who leaves any other way gets paid “not later than the next regularly scheduled payday.” § 61.014(b).
No demand. No letter. The six days run on their own.
Minnesota’s 24-hour rule is faster on paper, but it doesn’t start until the worker puts a demand in writing. The statute says the demand “must be in writing but need not state the precise amount of unpaid wages or commissions.” Minn. Stat. § 181.13(a). A fired Minnesotan who never writes that note has no 24-hour default and no penalty clock under § 181.13. A fired Texan has a deadline the day he walks out the door.
So if all you care about is the date the law says the check is due, without anybody lifting a pen, Texas wins. That’s where its advantage ends.
What happens when a Texas employer blows the deadline?
You file a wage claim with the Texas Workforce Commission. That’s the remedy the Payday Law builds, and it’s a good one for a small claim. It’s also a narrow one.
You have 180 days, and not one more. The claim “must be filed not later than the 180th day after the date the wages claimed became due for payment. The 180-day deadline is a matter of jurisdiction.” Tex. Lab. Code § 61.051(c). File late and “the examiner shall dismiss the wage claim for lack of jurisdiction.” § 61.052(b-1). The Commission’s own page tells claimants it “uses the date the wage claim is RECEIVED when determining if the claim is timely.”
An examiner decides it on paper. The Commission investigates and issues a preliminary wage determination order, either dismissing the claim or “ordering payment of wages determined to be due and unpaid.” § 61.052(a). Either side may ask for a hearing, but the request has to be in writing “not later than the 21st day after the date the commission examiner mails the notice” of the preliminary order. § 61.054(b). Miss that and the order “becomes the final order of the commission for all purposes, and neither party is entitled to judicial review” of it. § 61.055.
That 21-day window is not a technicality. In 2022 a Texas court of appeals affirmed the dismissal of a worker’s challenge to the denial of a $120,000 bonus claim because her hearing request came in one day late. Cooper v. Tex. Workforce Comm’n, No. 11-20-00246-CV, slip op. at 2, 7 (Tex. App.—Eastland July 21, 2022, no pet.) (mem. op.).
The penalty is small, optional, and not yours. Here’s the whole of it:
(a) If the commission examiner, a wage claim appeal tribunal, or the commission determines that an employer acted in bad faith in not paying wages as required by this chapter, the examiner, tribunal, or commission, in addition to ordering the payment of the wages, may assess an administrative penalty against the employer.
…
(c) An administrative penalty assessed under this section may not exceed the lesser of:
(1) the amount of the wages in question or claimed; or
(2) $1,000.
— Tex. Lab. Code § 61.053(a), (c)
Bad faith, not lateness. “May”, not “shall”. A ceiling of $1,000 no matter how big the claim. And then § 61.065: “The commission shall deposit a penalty collected under this subchapter in the unemployment compensation special administration fund”. The worker gets the wages the Commission collects “and any interest earned on those wages.” § 61.064.
And the same section that lets the Commission fine an employer for bad faith lets it fine the worker. If the Commission “determines an employee acted in bad faith in bringing a wage claim,” it “may assess an administrative penalty against the employee.” § 61.053(b). Minnesota’s penalty statute runs one direction. Texas’s runs both.
The Commission’s own wage-claim page tells you whose money the penalty is. It walks a claimant through filing, the preliminary order, appeals, and collection, and mentions the penalty only in passing: withdrawing a claim stops “charging the employer with a penalty”, and a worker who signs a satisfaction-of-payment form is told that “The employer will still be liable to TWC for any administrative penalties assessed on the claim.” Liable to TWC.
Can a Texas worker skip the agency and sue?
Yes. But the lawsuit doesn’t carry the Payday Law with it.
The Supreme Court of Texas took this up in 2008. A former employee claiming post-termination salary under his contract had filed a wage claim, lost it at the Commission, and then sued his employer for breach of contract in district court. The Court held that the agency route and the courthouse route are alternatives: “Payday Law actions do not abrogate common law claims against employers for an alleged failure to pay compensation. Rather, TWC offers an alternate means to the same remedy.” Igal, 250 S.W.3d at 88. But you pick one. “In Texas parlance, the claimant selects which horse to ride. Once the horse crosses the finish line, a claimant cannot switch horses and run the same race again, hoping for a different outcome.” Id. at 92. Because the worker in that case rode the agency horse to a final decision, res judicata barred his lawsuit. Id. at 81.
It was a 5-to-4 decision. The dissent said the majority had turned the Payday Law “into a trap where they may forfeit all their rights.” Id. at 93 (Brister, J., dissenting). And the Legislature didn’t wait long. The Igal majority had also held that the 180-day filing period, “while mandatory, is not jurisdictional”. Id. at 81. A year later, S.B. 741 rewrote § 61.051(c) to add the sentence that’s there now, “The 180-day deadline is a matter of jurisdiction”, and added the dismissal rule in § 61.052(b-1), for wage claims filed on or after September 1, 2009. Acts 2009, 81st Leg., R.S., ch. 21 (S.B. 741), §§ 1–4. The Senate Research Center’s bill analysis says why: under the Court’s ruling, “a claimant is unable to pursue their wage claim in court if TWC makes a determination that the wage claim was filed after the 180-day jurisdictional deadline.” The bill passed 31 to 0 in the Senate and 147 to 0 in the House.
So a Texan can sue. What he can’t do is bring the Payday Law’s penalty into court. A Houston court of appeals laid out the trade in 2010: “penalties can be recovered in a TWC claim but not in a breach of contract claim; in contrast, attorney’s fees can be recovered in connection with a breach of contract claim but not in a TWC claim.” Abatement Inc. v. Williams, 324 S.W.3d 858, 864 (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] 2010, pet. denied). And the Payday Law itself gives no private right to sue: “Chapter 61 provides a detailed administrative enforcement scheme and allows the possibility for enforcement by the attorney general, and nothing in language of chapter 61 shows any intent to also allow a private right of action.” Id.
The fee statute the court pointed to lets a person recover reasonable attorney’s fees from most defendants, though not from a religious organization, a charitable organization or trust, or certain quasi-governmental entities, “in addition to the amount of a valid claim and costs” if the claim is for “rendered services”, “performed labor”, or “an oral or written contract”, among others. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 38.001(b)(1), (2), (8). That’s real, but you get it only by winning a contract or services claim. A Texas worker in court gets his wages and maybe his fees. He doesn’t get a day’s pay for every day the employer stalled, because Texas never wrote that rule.
I looked for a Texas provision that pays the worker a late-payment penalty three ways. Chapter 61 has none. It has two civil penalties, and the State collects both: the bad-faith penalty in § 61.053, which § 61.065 deposits in a state fund, and a penalty of $1,000 for each failure to pay each employee on a surety company that wilfully fails to pay a verified wage claim, which “[t]he attorney general shall recover” in “an action brought in the name of the state.” § 61.033(a), (c). The Commission’s wage-claim page describes no worker penalty. And the Houston court in Abatement read the chapter to give no private right of action at all.
Texas made it a felony. Look at who it covers.
Texas does have a big stick. An employer commits an offense if, “at the time of hiring an employee, the employer intends to avoid payment of wages owed to the employee” and then “fails after demand to pay those wages.” Tex. Lab. Code § 61.019(a). It’s also an offense if the employer intends to avoid paying wages, “intends to continue to employ the employee”, and fails after demand to pay. § 61.019(b). Under subsection (b), every pay period the employer stiffs you is its own offense, and an offense under either subsection “is a felony of the third degree.” § 61.019(c), (d).
Read subsection (b) again. It’s aimed at the employer who keeps you working while it stiffs you. The fired worker isn’t someone the employer intends to keep employing, so on my reading, for the ordinary late final check, the felony comes down to subsection (a): proof that the employer planned not to pay you on the day it hired you. That’s a hard case for a prosecutor to make over a final check that’s two weeks late.
Minnesota has a criminal backstop too. Wage theft, committed when an employer “with intent to defraud” fails to pay wages owed, among other acts, is theft under the general theft statute. Minn. Stat. § 609.52, subd. 1(13), subd. 2(a)(19). I covered how that crime works, and why the wage notice is the evidence, at /news/minnesota-wage-theft-notice-181-032/. Neither state’s criminal statute is what gets a fired worker paid on Friday. The civil penalty is. One state has one.
The clocks for getting your money back
The Texas wage claim has to be filed within 180 days. Tex. Lab. Code § 61.051(c). A Texas contract suit runs longer; the Houston court in Abatement put a breach-of-contract claim at four years. 324 S.W.3d at 864 & n.4 (citing Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 16.004).
Minnesota gives a worker two years to sue “for the recovery of wages or overtime or damages, fees, or penalties accruing under any federal or state law respecting the payment of wages”, and three if the nonpayment “is willful and not the result of mistake or inadvertence” or the employer misses the Department of Labor and Industry’s deadline to turn over payroll records. Minn. Stat. § 541.07(5). That covers the § 181.13 penalty itself. The rest of Minnesota’s limitations periods are at /news/minnesota-statutes-of-limitations-civil-claims/.
And Minnesota has an agency route that pays the worker, not the state. When the Department of Labor and Industry issues a compliance order for a § 181.13 or § 181.14 violation, the commissioner “shall order the employer to pay to the aggrieved parties back pay, gratuities, and compensatory damages, less any amount actually paid to the aggrieved parties by the employer, and for an additional equal amount as liquidated damages.” Minn. Stat. § 177.27, subd. 7. An additional equal amount, to the aggrieved parties.
One more Texas point cuts in the worker’s favor. Texas counts vacation, holiday, sick leave, parental leave, and severance pay as “wages”, but only when “owed to an employee under a written agreement with the employer or under a written policy of the employer.” Tex. Lab. Code § 61.001(7)(B). Minnesota’s final-paycheck statute is about timing, and whether unused PTO is owed at all turns on the employer’s own documents, which I covered at /news/minnesota-unused-pto-payout/. On paid time off, the two states end up closer than you’d think.
So who protects the worker with the late check?
Minnesota, and it isn’t close.
Texas sets a deadline that runs without a demand, and that’s a genuine edge. Everything after the deadline is built for the state. The penalty needs bad faith, it’s capped at $1,000, it can be turned on the worker, and it’s deposited in a state fund. The worker who goes to court leaves the penalty behind.
Minnesota makes the worker do one thing, put the demand in writing, and then hands the worker the penalty, up to 15 days of average daily earnings, with mandatory fees if it comes to a lawsuit. The broader Minnesota rules on hours, overtime, and pay are at /news/minnesota-wage-and-hour-guide/. If you’re the employer, the Minnesota math is the reason to cut the check the day you let someone go.
In Texas, the fine for a late paycheck goes to the government. In Minnesota, it goes to the person who’s waiting for the check.
Madgett Law, LLC
Madgett Law, LLC represents Minnesota employers and departing employees in final-wage, commission, and unlawful-deduction disputes, including the good-faith tender that caps an employer’s exposure and the fee-shifting that doesn’t. Unpaid-wage disputes are part of the employment litigation on our general litigation page. If a final paycheck is in dispute, the first question is whether a written demand has gone out, and when. Send us a message.
Sources: Minn. Stat. § 181.13(a) (discharged employee; wages immediately due upon demand; 24-hour default; penalty of average daily earnings for each day up to 15 days; written demand need not state precise amount) and History line (1919 c 175 s 1); § 181.14, subd. 1(a) (quitting employee; first regularly scheduled payday; collective bargaining exception; five-day and 20-calendar-day provisions), subd. 2 (nonprompt payment; 24 hours after demand; penalty not exceeding 15 days); § 181.171, subds. 1, 3 (private civil action; mandatory costs, disbursements, witness fees, and attorney fees); § 177.27, subds. 4, 7 (compliance orders; back pay, compensatory damages, and an additional equal amount as liquidated damages to the aggrieved parties); § 541.07(5) (two years for wage claims; three years for willful nonpayment or failure to submit payroll records); § 609.52, subd. 1(13) (wage theft defined), subd. 2(a)(19) (wage theft as theft) (Minnesota Office of the Revisor of Statutes, 2026 Minnesota Statutes). Tex. Lab. Code § 61.001(2), (7)(B) (day means calendar day; wages include vacation, holiday, sick leave, parental leave, and severance pay owed under a written agreement or policy); § 61.014(a)–(b) (discharged employee paid not later than the sixth day; other separations, next regularly scheduled payday); § 61.019(a)–(d) (criminal offense; separate offense per pay period under subsection (b); third-degree felony); § 61.033(a), (c) (surety-company civil penalty recovered by the attorney general in the name of the state); § 61.051(c) (180-day deadline; matter of jurisdiction); § 61.052(a), (b-1) (preliminary wage determination order; dismissal of late claims); § 61.053(a)–(c) (bad-faith administrative penalty against employer or employee; lesser of wages or $1,000); § 61.054(b) (21 days to request hearing); § 61.055 (order final if hearing not requested); § 61.064 (payment of collected wages and interest to claimant); § 61.065 (penalty deposited in unemployment compensation special administration fund); Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 16.004(a) (four-year limitations period); § 38.001(b)(1), (2), (8) (attorney’s fees for rendered services, performed labor, oral or written contract; excluded defendants) (Texas Constitution and Statutes, Texas Legislative Council). S.B. 741, 81st Leg., R.S., §§ 1–4 (Tex. 2009) (enrolled; amending § 61.051(c) and adding § 61.052(b-1); applies to wage claims filed on or after September 1, 2009; vote certificates); Senate Research Center, Bill Analysis, S.B. 741, 81st Leg., R.S. (enrolled version, Sept. 21, 2009) (Texas Legislature Online). Texas Workforce Commission, Texas Payday Law – Wage Claim (twc.texas.gov). Igal v. Brightstar Info. Tech. Grp., Inc., 250 S.W.3d 78, 81, 88, 92 (Tex. 2008), and id. at 93 (Brister, J., dissenting); Abatement Inc. v. Williams, 324 S.W.3d 858, 864 & n.4 (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] 2010, pet. denied); Cooper v. Tex. Workforce Comm’n, No. 11-20-00246-CV, slip op. at 2, 7 (Tex. App.—Eastland July 21, 2022, no pet.) (mem. op.). This article is general legal information about Minnesota law, with Texas law for comparison. It is not legal advice, reading it does not create an attorney–client relationship, and no outcome is promised or implied.