Two sentences, two state legislatures, same subject.
Minnesota’s: “Nothing in sections 181.9445 to 181.9448 shall be construed to preempt, limit, or otherwise affect the applicability of any other law, regulation, requirement, policy, or standard that provides for a greater amount, accrual, or use by employees of paid sick and safe time or that extends other protections to employees.” Minn. Stat. § 181.9448, subd. 1(c).
Texas’s: a city or county “may not adopt, enforce, or maintain an ordinance, order, or rule regulating conduct in a field of regulation that is occupied by a provision of this code”, and that field “includes employment leave”. Tex. Lab. Code § 1.005(a), (b).
Minnesota wrote a floor and told everyone else they could build on it. Texas has no floor for private employers, and in 2023 it told its cities that if they build one, it’s void, and anybody hurt by it can sue the city for attorney’s fees.
This is another round in my Minnesota-vs-Texas series, which started with garnishment at /news/minnesota-vs-texas-wage-garnishment-571-922/ and most recently covered the late final paycheck at /news/minnesota-vs-texas-final-paycheck-penalty-181-13/. Some rounds in this series are close. This isn’t one of them.
What does Minnesota require?
Paid sick time for nearly every worker, since January 1, 2024. 2023 Minn. Laws ch. 53, art. 12, § 9.
The accrual rule is short: “An employee accrues a minimum of one hour of earned sick and safe time for every 30 hours worked up to a maximum of 48 hours of earned sick and safe time in a year.” Minn. Stat. § 181.9446(a). Unused hours carry over, but the bank “must not exceed 80 hours at any time, unless an employer agrees to a higher amount.” § 181.9446(b)(1). Time starts accruing on day one, and “Employees may use earned sick and safe time as it is accrued.” § 181.9446(d), (e). A full-time worker hits the 48-hour annual cap after 1,440 hours.
It covers almost everybody. An “employer” is “a person who has one or more employees”, public or private. § 181.9445, subd. 6. An “employee” includes “temporary and part-time employees” who are expected to work “at least 80 hours in a year for that employer in Minnesota.” § 181.9445, subd. 5. The uses run from your own illness to a sick kid, a funeral, a court proceeding after domestic abuse, and a school closed for a blizzard. § 181.9447, subd. 1. Retaliation is barred, and an attendance-point system can’t count the time against you. § 181.9447, subd. 6(a), (b). A person injured by a violation may sue for damages “together with costs and disbursements, including reasonable attorney’s fees”. § 181.944.
I walked the carryover rules, the attendance-point ban, and the recordkeeping trap for employers at /news/minnesota-earned-sick-and-safe-time/. For this round, the number is 48 hours a year, and the part that matters is subdivision 1(c): the state floor doesn’t stop anyone from going higher.
And Minnesota stacked Paid Leave on top of it
Sick time covers the dentist and the flu. Minnesota’s Paid Leave program, chapter 268B, covers the big stuff: a worker’s own serious health condition, bonding with a new child, caring for a family member, and safety leave. It’s state-run insurance, funded by a payroll premium that employers and employees split, with employers paying “a minimum of 50 percent”. Minn. Stat. § 268B.14, subd. 3. The statute caps the premium: “In no year shall the annual premium rate exceed 1.1 percent of taxable wages”. § 268B.14, subd. 7. The program’s own site puts the rate at 0.88% for 2026 and 2027.
The weekly benefit replaces 90 percent of a worker’s average weekly wage up to half the state’s average weekly wage, 66 percent of the part between half and all of the state average, and 55 percent of anything above it, with the benefit capped at the state’s average weekly wage. § 268B.04, subd. 3(a), (d). A worker can draw up to 12 weeks for one kind of leave and no more than 20 weeks combined in a benefit year. § 268B.04, subd. 5. And the job is protected: on return, an employee “is entitled to be returned to the same position the employee held when leave commenced or to an equivalent position”. § 268B.09, subd. 6(a).
The practical details for employers and employees are at /news/minnesota-paid-leave-now-in-effect/, and how it fits with pregnancy accommodation and parental leave is at /news/minnesota-pregnancy-accommodations-parental-leave/.
Does Texas have a paid sick leave law?
No. Not for private employers.
I checked it three ways. The Texas Payday Law treats sick pay as wages only when it’s promised: “Wages” include “sick leave pay” that is “owed to an employee under a written agreement with the employer or under a written policy of the employer.” Tex. Lab. Code § 61.001(7)(B). No policy, no wage. The Texas Workforce Commission’s guide for employers says it flatly: “No current Texas or federal law requires private-sector employers to provide paid or unpaid leave of any kind,” before noting that unpaid leave may be required as a disability or pregnancy accommodation and that the federal Family and Medical Leave Act covers employers with 50 or more employees nearby. And the Commission’s Payday Law page says the law “does not require an employer to offer fringe benefits such as vacation pay, holiday pay, or other pay for hours not worked.”
So in Texas, a sick day is paid if your employer wrote down that it would be. If it did, the Payday Law will hold it to the paper. If it didn’t, there’s nothing to enforce.
The cities tried. The courts stopped them.
Austin moved in February 2018. Its city council passed an ordinance requiring private employers to “grant an employee one hour of earned sick time for every 30 hours worked”, capped at 48 or 64 hours a year depending on the employer’s size. Tex. Ass’n of Bus. v. City of Austin, 565 S.W.3d 425, 430 (Tex. App.—Austin 2018, pet. denied). The same accrual rate Minnesota would adopt five years later.
It was scheduled to take effect October 1, 2018, and the court of appeals stayed it before that date. Id. A group of employers and business associations sued, the State of Texas intervened, and the Third Court of Appeals held that the ordinance was preempted by the Texas Minimum Wage Act. The hook was a 2003 sentence in that Act: “the minimum wage provided by this chapter supersedes a wage established in an ordinance, order, or charter provision governing wages in private employment, other than wages under a public contract.” Tex. Lab. Code § 62.0515(a). The question was whether paid sick time is a “wage”. The court said yes: the ordinance meant “employees who take sick leave are paid the same wage for fewer hours worked or, stated differently, that employees who take sick leave are paid more per hour for the hours actually worked.” 565 S.W.3d at 439–40. And so: “We hold that the Texas Minimum Wage Act preempts local regulations that establish a wage, that the Ordinance establishes a wage, and that, accordingly, the TMWA preempts the City’s Ordinance as a matter of law, thus making the Ordinance unconstitutional.” Id. at 440.
A statute that sets a minimum wage became the reason a city couldn’t give workers paid time off. That’s a creative use of a minimum-wage law.
Dallas passed its own version. In March 2021 a federal judge in the Eastern District of Texas permanently enjoined it on the same reasoning, noting that two Texas courts of appeals had already struck down “paid-sick-leave ordinances enacted by the City of Austin and the City of San Antonio, which mirror Dallas’s paid-sick-leave ordinance”. ESI/Employee Solutions, L.P. v. City of Dallas, No. 4:19-CV-570-SDJ, mem. op. at 1, 26 (E.D. Tex. Mar. 31, 2021), ECF No. 86. Its conclusion: “Because such an ordinance has the inevitable effect of increasing the pay of employees who use paid sick leave, it is preempted by the plain language of the TMWA and therefore unenforceable under the Texas Constitution.” Id. at 21.
Austin’s was ordered enjoined, San Antonio’s was held preempted, and Dallas’s was permanently enjoined. Three cities, three tries.
Then the Legislature made sure no city would try again
The 2023 Legislature passed H.B. 2127 and called it the Texas Regulatory Consistency Act. It found that “several local jurisdictions have sought to establish their own regulations of commerce that are different than the state’s regulations”, producing “a patchwork of regulations that apply inconsistently across this state.” H.B. 2127, 88th Leg., R.S., § 2 (Tex. 2023). The House committee’s bill analysis opened with the reason: “Cities and towns need relief from the pressure to duplicate state regulatory and enforcement efforts.”
On paid sick leave, there was no state effort to duplicate. The Act preempted the field anyway.
It wrote a preemption clause into eight Texas codes. In the Labor Code, it named the subjects:
(a) Unless expressly authorized by another statute, a municipality or county may not adopt, enforce, or maintain an ordinance, order, or rule regulating conduct in a field of regulation that is occupied by a provision of this code. An ordinance, order, or rule that violates this section is void, unenforceable, and inconsistent with this code.
(b) For purposes of Subsection (a), a field occupied by a provision of this code includes employment leave, hiring practices, breaks, employment benefits, scheduling practices, and any other terms of employment that exceed or conflict with federal or state law for employers other than a municipality or county.
— Tex. Lab. Code § 1.005 (emphasis added)
Then it gave the enforcement job to the private sector. Any person who “has sustained an injury in fact, actual or threatened,” from a city or county rule adopted or enforced in violation of § 1.005, “or a trade association representing the person”, may sue the city or county. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 102A.002(5). The winner is “entitled to recover” declaratory and injunctive relief and “costs and reasonable attorney’s fees.” § 102A.003(a). The city’s governmental immunity “is waived to the extent of liability created by this chapter.” § 102A.004. The city gets three months’ notice before the suit is filed. § 102A.005. And if the suit is frivolous, the city can recover its fees. § 102A.003(b).
The Act passed the House 92 to 55 and the Senate 18 to 13. That isn’t two-thirds of either chamber, so it took effect September 1, 2023, under its own effective-date clause. H.B. 2127, § 17.
Notice the last clause of § 1.005(b): the field is occupied by terms of employment “that exceed or conflict with federal or state law”. State law sets no sick-leave floor for private employers. So any city sick-leave rule for private employers exceeds it. A city can still give its own workforce more. The field in § 1.005(b) covers terms of employment “for employers other than a municipality or county”, and the Act says it “does not affect the authority of a municipality or county to” “adopt a policy related to its employees”. H.B. 2127, § 4(5)(B). Austin can give Austin’s clerks a sick day. It can’t make the coffee shop down the street do it.
Is the Texas law even constitutional?
Nobody has gotten a final answer yet.
Houston sued the State before the Act took effect, and San Antonio and El Paso joined. A Travis County district court declared the whole Act unconstitutional. On July 18, 2025, the Third Court of Appeals reversed and dismissed the suit, not because the Act is valid, but because the cities lacked standing to bring it against the State. State v. City of Houston, No. 03-23-00531-CV, slip op. at 1–3, 17 (Tex. App.—Austin July 18, 2025). The court held the cities hadn’t shown a concrete injury, since they challenged the Act on its face without pointing to an actual local regulation it would void, and that their injuries weren’t traceable to the State: “No amount of repleading will show that the State of Texas is a proper defendant.” Id. at 2–3. The judgment dismissed the suit “without prejudice for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction.” Id. at 17.
The court of appeals denied rehearing and en banc reconsideration on April 15, 2026. Two justices would have reheard it, and one of them filed a dissent on May 14, 2026, opening with the Act’s nickname: the “Death Star Bill,” as it “is widely known.” The cities petitioned the Supreme Court of Texas on June 29, 2026, in No. 26-0521. On July 24, 2026 the Court ordered the State to respond. The State filed its response on October 7, the cities replied on October 22, and the petition is still pending.
The way that opinion reads, the fight over H.B. 2127 will come when someone uses it, a trade association suing a city over a real ordinance, not when a city sues the State in the abstract. For paid sick leave, the courts had already done the State’s work under the minimum-wage statute before H.B. 2127 was ever filed.
What does federal law add?
Not pay. The Family and Medical Leave Act gives eligible employees job-protected time off, but outside a pandemic provision that ran through December 31, 2020, that leave “may consist of unpaid leave”, and the statute says outright that “nothing in this subchapter shall require an employer to provide paid sick leave or paid medical leave in any situation in which such employer would not normally provide any such paid leave.” 29 U.S.C. § 2612(a)(1)(F), (c), (d)(2)(B). So for a private-sector Texan, the paid sick day comes from the employer’s own written policy or it doesn’t come.
So who protects the worker who gets sick?
Minnesota, by a mile.
A Minnesota worker earns paid sick time by statute from the first day on the job, up to 48 hours a year and an 80-hour bank, with a right to sue and recover attorney’s fees if the employer gets it wrong. On top of that sits a state insurance program that pays up to 20 weeks a year for serious illness, a new child, or a sick family member, with the job held open. And the statute invites anyone to do better.
A Texas worker gets what’s in the employee handbook. The Texas cities that tried to write a minimum lost in court, and the Legislature then gave employers and trade associations a fee-shifting lawsuit against any city that tries again. The Texas Legislature’s own word for what it was fixing was “patchwork”. In Texas the patchwork was three cities trying to give workers a sick day.
Texas employers do get one thing out of this: a single rule statewide, and the rule is that the State requires nothing. Whether that’s a virtue depends on whether you’re the one signing the paychecks or the one running a fever.
Minnesota wrote a floor and said go higher. Texas left the floor out for private employers and voided any city rule that tries to build one.
Madgett Law, LLC
Madgett Law, LLC handles Minnesota employment disputes on both sides, including sick-time and leave claims, retaliation over the use of protected leave, and the policy and handbook questions that decide whether an employer is in compliance. Employment disputes are part of our general litigation practice. If you were disciplined or let go after using sick time or taking leave, or you run a business and aren’t sure your policy meets the statute, send us a message.
Sources: Minn. Stat. § 181.944 (individual remedies; attorney’s fees); § 181.9445, subds. 5–6 (employee; employer); § 181.9446(a), (b)(1), (d), (e) (accrual of one hour per 30 hours worked up to 48 hours a year; 80-hour cap; accrual from commencement; use as accrued); § 181.9447, subd. 1 (eligible uses), subd. 6(a)–(b) (retaliation; attendance points); § 181.9448, subd. 1(c) (no preemption of more generous law); § 268B.04, subd. 3(a), (d) (weekly benefit; maximum), subd. 5 (12- and 20-week limits); § 268B.09, subd. 6(a) (reinstatement); § 268B.14, subd. 3 (employer pays at least 50 percent), subd. 7 (1.1 percent cap) (Minnesota Office of the Revisor of Statutes, 2026 Minnesota Statutes); 2023 Minn. Laws ch. 53, art. 12, § 9 (article effective January 1, 2024); Minnesota Paid Leave, Premium rate and contributions (pl.mn.gov) (0.88 percent for 2026 and 2027). Tex. Lab. Code § 1.005(a)–(b) (preemption; employment leave); § 61.001(7)(B) (sick leave pay as wages when owed under a written agreement or policy); § 62.0515(a) (minimum wage supersedes local wage ordinances); Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 102A.002(5), § 102A.003, § 102A.004, § 102A.005 (cause of action; remedies; immunity waiver; notice) (Texas Constitution and Statutes, Texas Legislative Council); H.B. 2127, 88th Leg., R.S., §§ 2, 4(5)(B), 10, 17 (Tex. 2023) (enrolled; findings; cities’ authority over their own employees; Labor Code § 1.005; effective date; vote certificates) and House Committee on State Affairs, Bill Analysis, C.S.H.B. 2127 (Committee Report, Substituted) (Texas Legislature Online). Texas Workforce Commission, Especially for Texas Employers, “Vacation and Sick Leave”, and Texas Payday Law – Wage Claim (twc.texas.gov). Tex. Ass’n of Bus. v. City of Austin, 565 S.W.3d 425, 430, 439–40 (Tex. App.—Austin 2018, pet. denied) (Caselaw Access Project); ESI/Employee Solutions, L.P. v. City of Dallas, No. 4:19-CV-570-SDJ, mem. op. at 1, 21, 26 (E.D. Tex. Mar. 31, 2021), ECF No. 86; State v. City of Houston, No. 03-23-00531-CV, slip op. at 1–3, 17 (Tex. App.—Austin July 18, 2025), and No. 03-23-00531-CV, slip op. at 1 (Tex. App.—Austin May 14, 2026) (Crump, J., dissenting from denial of en banc reconsideration); Third Court of Appeals docket, No. 03-23-00531-CV (rehearing denied Apr. 15, 2026); Supreme Court of Texas docket, No. 26-0521 (petition for review filed June 29, 2026; response ordered July 24, 2026; response Oct. 7, 2026; reply Oct. 22, 2026). 29 U.S.C. § 2612(a)(1)(F), (c), (d)(2)(B) (United States Code, 2024 ed., govinfo). This article is general legal information about Minnesota law, with Texas and federal law for comparison. It is not legal advice, reading it does not create an attorney–client relationship, and no outcome is promised or implied.